World War I, also known as the First World War or the Great War, was a global War originating in Europe that lasted from 28 July 1914 to 11 November 1918. This week saw the Centenary anniversary of the end of the war and the allied success in maintaining world freedom.

WW1 provided many significant items of memorabilia for collectors, with some holding substantial financial value. Collections typically mean more than any potential economic benefit, with patriotism and family heritage the primary interest.

Medals are a favoured item of collection, and collectors are often faced with the challenges of deciding what to collect and being sure of the item’s authentication.  Many antique dealers and war militaria specialists, can assist with the values associated with individual medals or collections, and support in drawing out the incredible history and stories related to these great symbols of bravery and freedom.

WW1 medals generally hold higher value than WW2 medals, due to the engraved name of soldiers on WW1 medals only.  With around 18 million medals engraved in WW1, it has long been speculated that the logistical and financial burden of inscribing medals wasn’t something the UK was prepared to tackle a second time.

Medal values hold to any other asset – they are only worth what someone is willing to pay, but the attached storyboard to each medal provides provenance to the history of the medal and is a crucial factor for those who collect.  Specific battles, campaigns, regiments and rank are some of the features that determine the value of a medal or a set.

A WW1 service medal can be purchased for around £10, with the highest medal sale on record at £1.5m for a Victoria Cross awarded to First World War Captain Noel Chavasse, one of only three people to have received two VCs. Famous battles such as the first vs the Germans at MONS, would fetch 3 to 4 times more than other battles for the same medal (eg a Distinguished Service Order from MONs, values at around £4k).

Two highlights of the collections of our clients are the set of Colonel Colmer William Donald Lynch, famous for “when the barrage lifts…”, and the 1st July 1916 Battle of the Somme. The other is the collection of medals awarded to Ada Emily Francis, Queen Mary’s Army Auxiliary Corps (QMAAC), from Harlow in Essex.

The story of Lynch goes back to the eve of the Battle of the Somme, when all of the officers of the 9th King’s Own Yorkshire Light Infantry (KOYLI) met for a final time, before facing the trenches at Fricourt (Somme).

C.W.D.Lynch had been with the unit since 1915 and was awarded the Distinguished Service Order (DSO)for bravery at Loos (France).  He was a pedantic disciplinarian and disliked by all.  Lancelot Spicer, then an officer in the battalion, recalled the incident in his memoirs:

At about 6pm on June 28th, all officers received a summons to go to Battalion HQ for a final drink before going into action.  We assembled, glasses were put into our hands, drinks were passed around, and we drank quietly to one another – everyone was naturally feeling strained.  The Adjutant and Second-in-command were away on some course, so the Acting Adjutant, Keay, was in charge.  Lynch came into the room and was given a glass.  Keay went up to Haswell, the senior Captain, and said quietly to him:

‘I think you should propose the CO’s (Commanding Officer) health!’

‘I’m damned if I will’, said Haswell ‘I don’t wish him good health and am not prepared to be insincere on this occasion.’

‘You must’, said Keay.

‘I won’t.’, said Haswell.

For a few moments they argued, and then Haswell stepped forward and raising his glass said:

‘Gentlemen, I give you the toast of the King’s Own Yorkshire Light Infantry, and in particular the 9th Battalion of the Regiment’ – a slight pause – ‘Gentleman, when the barrage lifts…’

We emptied our glasses and were silent. Dramatically, Haswell had avoided an unpleasant scene, and the toast has never been forgotten.

Of those present, twenty-four went into action next day in the attack on Fricourt.  Six were in reserve.  Of the twenty-four, twelve were killed, including Lynch and Haswell.  Three died of wounds afterwards, eight were wounded, one slightly and only one left untouched.

The bodies of Lynch and Haswell were recovered from the battlefield and buried in Norfolk Cemetery, Becourt.  Over three million men fought in the Battle of the Somme, and one million were either killed or wounded, in what was the largest Battle of the First World War on the Western Front.

Ada Emily Francis, QMAAC, from Harlow in Essex, was one of many women who supported the efforts of the allies, providing the expertise for the infrastructure behind the men in the trenches.

Before the War, Francis was a typist and shorthand writer, and she was one of 100,000 women who signed up to the QMAAC, which was established in December 1916, initially as the Women’s Army Auxiliary Corps (WAAC).  On the 3rd June 1919, Francis was awarded the MBE (Military) for her services to Field Marshall Sir Evelyn Wood VC.

It’s essential that collectors take steps to ensure their treasured possessions are adequately insured. Most ‘antiques’ aren’t suitable for standard mass market home insurance policies, and are likely to be underinsured if indeed covered.

It is advisable to check your current insurance arrangements and confirm cover is in place, and your collection is correctly valued.

Most collections that move into the “high net worth” category upwards of £10k, will need specialist insurance, which isn’t readily available online.  At Provenance, we understand the insurance market for specialist items and have relationships with the principal underwriters, to guarantee the correct cover is in place.

Our advice to all collectors is to ensure up to date valuations, a home inventory, retain copies of invoices/purchases, and any appraisals on the item’s history and past ownership.  Photographs are the perfect storage record and are also easy to store online.

For both the hobbyist and the serious collector, we recommend taking a look at https://www.mccarthymedals.com/

 

 

Jason Connon
CEO
Provenance Insurance Brokers